GraemeS's latest activity
-
Pretty much same as above, with the addition of a number 4 4) There's a foul/handball, I see it, I blow. But I don't know if it's in or...
-
GraemeS reacted to Runner Ref's post in the thread Australian A-League - Macarthur v Sydney with
Like.
Just not great officiating all round. No need for VAR to get involved whatsoever there, and really poor from the referee to change their... -
GraemeS replied to the thread Everton - Forest.How many games has your fictional manager refereed in front of hundreds? This is a theoretical suggested improvement. Current IFAB...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Australian A-League - Macarthur v Sydney.The overarching trend in England is of too much caution when it comes to the VAR getting involved. So my guess is that it's much more...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Everton - Forest.Charitable reading - Clatts phoned Webb to ask him if this was a conflict of interests, he/Forest considered that putting in a request...
-
I'd buy this if a Forest loss benefitted Luton clearly, but a draw is arguably a better result because Luton play Everton in the coming...
-
Spot on. Clattenburg knew exactly what he was doing in making that request/comment to PGMOL beforehand - any controversial decision was...
-
I agree about retired officals not always best suited for VAR. I would add the noise in the VAR room must make it incredibly difficult...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Everton - Forest.And I think that's an argument that needs to be examined and considered - not just accepted as irrefutable truth as it seems to be now.
-
GraemeS replied to the thread City vs Chelsea.Fair enough, correction noted - but I don't think it materially changes the point I was making.
-
@GraemeS They aren't FIFA directives, they're UEFA ones. They'll be another set of instructions when they go off for a World Cup...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Everton - Forest.Fully aware that I'm stereotyping, but it's not typical that older people are the most comfortable with technology. I'd love a VAR to be...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Coventry - Man Utd.Because not celebrating due to the possibility of VAR is a choice. Some people prefer to preserve the initial celebration moment and...
-
GraemeS replied to the thread Everton - Forest.Nope, I'm with you - there's enough of an attempt on the ball that yellow would have been uncontroversial.
-
I think 2 (or more) interpretations is exactly what we have. But this is also like the prem mantra to avoid cards and keep 11 on the...
