ladbroke8745
RefChat Addict
Just wow
Right at the end it showed a neutral assistant...No neutral assistants in the A-League?
I took it to be the coaches for something they said as well, with the first 2 being dissent 2nd yellows too!What happened for the 5th one - where there is noise in the distance? Was it more verbals?
Is it that 5 of 7 were for OFFINABUS?
And the two coaches for repeated technical area offences?
The 2nd coach RC seemed pernicious. Other than that, good going son!
I wasn't sure if he meant 1 minute left to play or 1 minute for the dismissed players and officials to disappear to wherever it is he wanted them to go. Later in the same phase of discussion he looks at his watch and says '30 seconds'.At one point in the video he says "1 minute left", which going by the video description, I take to mean 1 minute to the end of the match. With that in mind, I think although technically right in law, he could easily have "chosen not to notice" the fact that the first 2 sending off's weren't leaving the area and just got on with forcing the game through to the end.
I thought that was a "unless he departs in one minute, the game is over."At one point in the video he says "1 minute left", which going by the video description, I take to mean 1 minute to the end of the match. With that in mind, I think although technically right in law, he could easily have "chosen not to notice" the fact that the first 2 sending off's weren't leaving the area and just got on with forcing the game through to the end.
How incorrect? If he'd already shown the second yellow, the red is the only thing left to show.Did he miss a second yellow early in the clip? He waves a yellow card at Red No 3 (around 40 seconds in) but then a yellow player comes across apparently indicating that it was his second booking. Referee seems to check his book and issues a straight red to Red No 3. I appreciate the card sequence would be incorrect but it looked like a second yellow to me.
You're right, my mistake.How incorrect? If he'd already shown the second yellow, the red is the only thing left to show.
Yeah, he definitely wasn't aware that he was showing a second yellow at that point. It's possible he would have checked anyway without the "two" from the yellow player, but that definitely sped it up.Did he miss a second yellow early in the clip? He waves a yellow card at Red No 3 (around 40 seconds in) but then a yellow player comes across apparently indicating that it was his second booking. Referee seems to check his book and issues a straight red to Red No 3. I appreciate the card sequence would be incorrect but it looked like a second yellow to me.
Yeah, you may well be right - the video description says "in the last 5 minutes" though, so either way I think there's a case for not causing a fuss over those two hanging around behind the dugout, getting away from the area/leave his AR to deal with it and just get to the end of the match. If all they want at that point is to stand behind the dugout and see if their team makes it to the next round or not, you're better off not having that argument - only need to get involved if they're committing further misconduct from just off the field.I thought that was a "unless he departs in one minute, the game is over."
I agree he gets points for staying calm, which must have been tough, but I thought his biggest mistake was not getting away from the touch line after the first send off--no reason to stay there to write it in the book. That doesn't excuse any of the misconduct, but why be there?
I was trying to figure out if he had changed where he kept his red, or was just a bit flustered as he reached different places a couple of times.