A&H

Recent content by spuddy1878

  1. S

    Forest v Newcastle

    Yeah just seen the Gary Neville clip from last night. It gives 5 bullet points and this incident probably doesn't tick four of the boxes, the only one that saves him is the fact he's stretching. I know personal opinion shouldn't come into it but i find that the wrong decision.
  2. S

    Newport v Bradford keeper handball

    Too many doubts to go red here. The ball might well run behind, is it a 3g pitch so the ball will roll quicker. Agree about the lines though, very confusing.
  3. S

    Forest v Newcastle

    What does the law say now about a deliberate play ? Surely if someone is stretching and making an attempt to play the ball thats deliberate.
  4. S

    Thoughts on this, causing some debate.

    Penalty or not ?
  5. S

    GHA vs URU Matchday 12 - Siebert (GER)

    Not a penalty on Cavani, the one on Nunez more a penalty. No wonder there is a lack of referees and a lack of respect when you're getting scenes like that after the full time whistle. The ref was very strong there but should have stood his ground and anyone approaching just issue with cards
  6. S

    Matchday 11 - CRC v GER - Frappart (FRA)

    While this is true surely from the original pass (not to him) hes gaining an advantage by being in the position hes in.
  7. S

    Top VAR drama!

    Regarding the Ath Madrid incident. I get the final whistle had gone and VAR advised a penalty, surely if the game had finished should the penalty kick be the last action or is it until the ball is completely dead, i was under the impression once the penalty is taken thats the end of the game.
  8. S

    Top VAR drama!

    Sorry not seen the Madrid drama yet.
  9. S

    Top VAR drama!

    Which handball, they haven't given handball if we are talking about Spurs here. I just cant see how they've given offside here.
  10. S

    Disciplinary hearing

    Im not 100% sure i did, i emailed my league to give them a report of the incident but cant be sure if i submitted an extraordinary report.
  11. S

    Disciplinary hearing

    About 4-5 weeks ago i gave an U13s manager two yellow cards in a game. This week ive got a hearing via zoom (or similar) He is disputing the charge. Is there anything i should be doing in preparation, ive got notes from the day and im a bit nervous about it but does anyone have any tips or...
  12. S

    Everton V Newcastle

    Amazed that some people actually think this is SFP. Its a trip, its on his foot, not his knees, shins or higher than that. Its cynical yes but there is nothing in the laws to suggest a cynical foul is a red card. Its a reckless challenge which the referee has a clear view of from 7/8 yards...
  13. S

    Liverpool vs Chelsea

    Cant believe there was a thread on this and the Keita challenge has only just been brought up. Its one of the easiest red cards you will see for me, i dont blame the referee (who had an excellent game) but how can VAR look at that and think its not a red card.
  14. S

    Brighton v Newcastle

    If you're showing a new referee what an example of DOGSO is this is probably the clip you'd show him.
  15. S

    VAR

    While on the subject of VAR. The Everton game today, the penalty incident which the referee gave at the time. I can see both sides, penalty and none penalty and i imagine opinion will be split on it but what i dont get is why has Jon Moss in the VAR got involved, the var is there for clear and...
Back
Top