Search results

Your bottom line basically backs up my point, i didnt say you would sack the person. But would you favour them going forward? Would you promote that person?

@Padfoot are you being controversial just for the sake of it again??? Employers will police social media because they will want to protect the image of the company and not have it brought into disrepute, the FA are no different. "Not been to sleep all weekend, what a mad one. Seriously what did...

I would have to go caution and re-take in both situations, providing you are absolutely certain that the distraction was enough to put the player off. @PinnerPaul it cant be either or they both have to be the same sanction. A penalty is just a direct free kick in the penalty area.

Are you up for promotion? If you are not then you will not be observed, simple as that. You should though have been assigned a mentor and he/she should be available to talk things through with and maybe attend a game or two.

In terms of your point on experience, i think that would depend on what games are being done. Yes, an academy referee may have great positioning and looked very polished on the pitch. But can he manage mental Dave who plays centre back for the Red Lion? How will he deal with having 4 or 5...

Well i have heard Mark Saggers talk some guff but i think he may have excelled himself with this article. No yellow or red cards and a 15 minute sin bin for headbutting a player........https://you-are-the-ref.com/mark-saggers-heres-radical-plan-keep-playing-field-level/

Ditto

So last night was the League meeting of the local league i sit on the committee for, 50 club secretaries were in attendance. We mentioned that we have been asked if we wish to take part in the pilot and that we would be asking for opinions via email in the next few weeks. We asked for some...

This is a great point!!!

@PinnerPaul is refering to a report he has read, he wasn't on the line. Read the OP properly before having a go.

You make it sound so easy. Without neutral assistants and with more than one player in the "sin bin" it will be a nightmare. Seeing as it has never been tried before then all we can do is focus on the issues we think it can cause.

@PP62 just took the words from my mouth, its an opinion not an excuse. In my opinion its a bad idea. Just out of interest, if managing this will be so easy. How do manage the multiple dismissals? I know I am playing devils advocate here as it doesn't happen often. But if you have more than one...

Sorry for a second their I thought you said get the managers to manage the dismissal.......oh wait!!!!!! The reason I gave for it "possibly" increasing dissent is because it may actually discourage certain ref's from issuing the dissent caution as they don't want to have to handle the dismissal...

100% with @Padfoot on this it is going to be such a headache for the lone referee. A league i officiate on has been asked to pilot this. Imagine this.... A player is cautioned for dissent and is sin binned, 3.5 minutes later you have to bin another and 2 minutes after that you need to bin...

Red all day long for me and i am a red but as soon as i saw it i said to my mates thats it he is off. What would you be sending Aguero off for? Yes he went head to head with him but that is a max of AA which is a caution. Fellaini then butts him, clear as day. He is a 24 carrat idiot for what...

I was told last year was extended due to the extended marking season, don't know how true that is. Longest wait of my life this......!!!