Search results

I think this was one where Luiz cracked Jimenez’s headthat Arsenal got away with a few seasons back. To me it is late and a foul. I think this whole ‘in the box’ threshold nonsense needs to go. If it’s a foul, it’s a foul.

This is a really tough one. I think it is unfortunate. That is my thought. The first one is purely accidental, second I think is avoidable, but not sure if deliberate act. A really difficult one - it would definitely fall under the SFP instead of VC imho.

My issue is the change of direction once he has slipped. He had the chance to pull out of it.

Pundits saying it’s not reckless but it’s out of control so not a red…. Crikey… Also - it doesn’t matter if it is an accident.

I know that this is decisive, but I do use RefSix for timings and goals AND write on card stickers. I do both because both have let me down on at least one occasion. (The card due to sweat and bad handwriting, and the watch do to me not charging it properly!! - both user error). REFSIX app is...

MUFC V THFC Think I totally agree with the red. The slip happened, but then, when out of control he continued to change direction of leg. Think it ticks the boxes for the SFP: Height, control of body, speed of impact, studs showing. For the neutral it’s quite a good game - end to end stuff.

Petulance by both. Brighton player clearly knew he would make contact, but not brutal or ‘violent’. But also Rice being a muppet. Only has himself to blame here. CK did miss the one earlier, perhaps have BotD as was far from the whistle? Either way, players must learn if you play with fire...

Touchlines (both types). They’re brilliant. Have some shocking Amazon flags for club ARs.

Ahh ha. Good refereeing then, I’d say. BBD clearly briefed to wind him up to get a reaction.

You put your head towards another players head, you make the decision for the ref. Ref did the right thing, but the initial foul should also warrant a caution as was unnecessary.

I think if it’s given as a foul; it is reckless. But I’m very red and white bias. So tough to be impartial.

It happened!! Indirect FK for an offside inside the box. Defender lightly touches it and kicks it again! Takes me a second to work out what happened (as was totally uncontested and keeper just behind - so no need to do it at all). Blow and give an IFK to attacking team. No caution or red as...

My pennies worth… Football comments: Pen 1: Would be soft. Seen them given, but not convinced. Pen 2: I think based on the interpretation of the LOTG this season it is a pen. I think the law is incorrect, but these have been given a lot! Pen 3: I think this is a nailed on penalty...

^^ This

So irritating and expensive! But I will still buy the new ones!

I think it was good refereeing but also could have been given as a HB. Think players were extremely lucky. Will probably be used as a clip for ref training in the future!

The only bit I really saw was the pen appeal at the end. Outstanding refereeing. If anything was a foul on the keeper. CL refereeing is really quite impressive.

That’s too cold for me! I’d have to cry off with that!! (Joking!)

Agree - inside the box?

If observed any RC or PK is considered a KMI. But it’s also something that we are expected to get right as referees. (However - if there is any doubt at all - you do have discretion - e.g. that really really fast defender that would have made it *cough*)