A&H

Search results

  1. J

    Red Cards Make a Debut

    It's hard to remember what the FA have made up and what's actually in the book sometimes. The FA codes barely make sense.
  2. J

    Mings Handball

    You don't think a top premier league striker is 'likely' to gain possession there? I think so. However, it really doesn't scream DOGSO and there is no expectation. But I think Vardy is 'likely' to gain possession.
  3. J

    Dutch Referee Blog - Week 20 Laws of the Game Quiz 2019-2020

    The 'proper' call in Q2 is in the book. Calling a circular that nobody reads the 'proper' call is confusing. This is to be changed for the upcoming season though.
  4. J

    Mings Handball

    Do we think the lines on the Villa kit have swayed the decision? "It hit the blue part, so it must be arm..."
  5. J

    Mings Handball

    Not sure how there's no card when that has been given...
  6. J

    Mings Handball

  7. J

    When to show a red card? (Sin bin)

    What's the actual answer? Are they classed as simultaneous offences?
  8. J

    Sinbin then red.

    Because sent off implies red card. It is not a red card offence to be cautioned whilst in the sin bin, but in effect it is the same.
  9. J

    Sinbin then red.

    Red card is not shown but that player cannot return or be replaced.
  10. J

    Giving players information.

    Keeper asked me today and I obliged:)
  11. J

    tottenham v norwich penalties

    There's no doubt the assistant saw the infringements. Unfortunately (in England anyway) it is an issue of don't bring unnessesary attention to yourself. Numerous times I have had pre-matches from referees that say 'there will be no retakes on penalties, don't put your flag up' - this is quite...
  12. J

    Gloves on pitch

    Unless they were dangerous, I can't see why I'd stop play. Next stoppage will do.
  13. J

    Handball clarifications

    So it's just like I said it was;)
  14. J

    GK Handball in the Middle of the Pitch

    If you gave red, nobody would complain and it would probably be the more 'just' outcome. If we are strictly talking law, I believe it is a caution because law says 'denying a goal' not 'denying a probable goal'. I think this is just a situation where you could go either way and justify it.
  15. J

    Everton

    Confronting the match officials at half-time or full-time by a team official is a red card offence. Once you have decided they are confronting you, you have no scope to give a caution.
  16. J

    Everton

    Yes, there are different provisions in law for this. I am more talking about what is fair vs what law says.
  17. J

    Everton

    It seems crazy that Klopp, Pep and Jose can react as they do on the touchline and they are never sanctioned. Yet because it is full-time, Ancelotti is sent off for 'confronting' the match officials. Pep was much worse in the game against Liverpool and Jose sprinted towards Graham Scott recently...
  18. J

    Everton

    I don't think so, looks like Kavanagh warns Ancelotti to leave and you can hear Ancelotti saying "I'm staying here", then he reaches for the red.
  19. J

    GK Handball in the Middle of the Pitch

    There's a difference between ignoring the 6-second rule and ignoring something with relation to a red card. You admit that if you could see it was missing, you'd accept a caution was correct. All we are saying is that if we could see it WASN'T missing, we'd accept a dismissal would be correct...
  20. J

    GK Handball in the Middle of the Pitch

    Nothing secret about learning the laws of the game.
Back
Top