The Ref Stop

Studs up and a push in the back - A League

Murri O

Well-Known Member
If this isn't geoblocked could some here offer an opinion on the 2 incidents shown. Ignore Bosnich's self proclaimed 'I'm an expert' carry on. (We're short on good football commentators here.)

https://theworldgame.sbs.com.au/vid...WoLCctl0ztgC_PIUJvMJN3PhkNx_bHDuO2ISyuoEXHJsE

For me the studs up tackle is at least a yellow if not a red and the push in the box, from behind with an arm, is a penalty. Wondering if the penalty is given then a red should follow for a DOGSO?

(Alternate link here to pen call. https://www.foxsports.com.au/video/football/a-league/expert-bozza-puts-foot-down!781105 )
and (studs up challenge here https://www.foxsports.com.au/video/football/a-league/should-duke-have-been-sent!781045 )
 
Last edited:
The Ref Stop
Red card for the sliding challenge any day of the week.

Not 100% sure I'd be giving the pen, i can see why, but depending on the angle i can think the contact could look less than it is. If i did give it, RC for DOGSO.
 
The tackle warrants a red - no doubt.

The push in the back is a penalty too, followed by a red for the defender's deliberate nature in the challenge.
 
Res for the tackle and a red and penalty for the push.

If a player commits a dogso offence through pushing or pulling an opponent it has to be a red card.
 
Both are somewhere in the middle and different referees make different decisions. No matter what decision made, VAR should stay it of it.

Tackle is yellow for me. I would have given red if he was off the ground.

Push a penalty DOGSO. Defenders should know not to force the ref into a decision like that. He got lucky there.
 
Both are somewhere in the middle and different referees make different decisions. No matter what decision made, VAR should stay it of it.

Tackle is yellow for me. I would have given red if he was off the ground.

Push a penalty DOGSO. Defenders should know not to force the ref into a decision like that. He got lucky there.
Take a very closer look at the tackle again and really analyze it and see if u come up with the same YC judgement
 
Yeap. I analysed it before and it was yellow. I really analysed it now and it's still yellow. Should I really really analyse it to see if I change my mind ? :)
Okay if u said u did all that and still remains yellow den, yellow it is.. cheers
 
Back
Top