Did a game yesterday (under 18s) where both keepers fouled an opponent with DOGSO.
On one there was a clear attempt to get the ball but got the attacker first by a fraction of a second.
On the second the keeper got the attacker with his feet (a bit like the one in the PGMO Dogso video chelsea keeper v Man city 12 mins in) .
www.dropbox.com/s/uir0x4bs95tllf1/PGMO%20Conference%202016%20Workshop%20-%20DOGSO.mp4?dl=0
For me it was not a genuine attempt to get the ball BUT the video says it is a yellow card. In my my heart i wanted to show red but:
This video tells me not to
AND
Both teams would be possibly confused if i sent one off and not the other.
Asking a referee for opinions like the FA does now is dangerous as inconsistency causes chaos!
I'd love some opinions.
On one there was a clear attempt to get the ball but got the attacker first by a fraction of a second.
On the second the keeper got the attacker with his feet (a bit like the one in the PGMO Dogso video chelsea keeper v Man city 12 mins in) .
www.dropbox.com/s/uir0x4bs95tllf1/PGMO%20Conference%202016%20Workshop%20-%20DOGSO.mp4?dl=0
For me it was not a genuine attempt to get the ball BUT the video says it is a yellow card. In my my heart i wanted to show red but:
This video tells me not to
AND
Both teams would be possibly confused if i sent one off and not the other.
Asking a referee for opinions like the FA does now is dangerous as inconsistency causes chaos!
I'd love some opinions.