A&H

Arsenal Vs Man Utd

Ori said:
Are you sensuous? Evans starts by pulling on his shirt by the neck which in itself is dangerous. View attachment 6810
Click to expand...

Great picture. Not seen that. I'd be insterested to see the entire vid from that angle.
50/50 if the ball has entered play but yes be a hard sell for a defensive FK if it had.
Like I said the grappling in the box is ignored. I'd be all for the likes of this being called a penalty.

1693869491963.png
 
The Referee Store
RustyRef said:
It simply isn't a foul on Evans, and as far as I can see the only people who thought it was are associated in someway with his club. If anything it would be a penalty as Evans holds Gabriel first, although obviously not as a goal was scored.
Click to expand...

​

Magalhaes is doing absolutely nothing except blocking Evans from getting to the ball. His movement in the video is not the movement of a player trying to get to a ball or move into a better position. His wide stance gives away that he does not plan on being moved.
He doesn't even attempt to jump for the ball that goes just over his head.

Watching the vid, it looks like a well rehearsed routine he executes it so perfectly.

We can say Evans fouls him before/after, but Evans is absolutely being fouled.

Once again, I do not expect these to be called.

1693869913664.png
 
deusex said:

​

Magalhaes is doing absolutely nothing except blocking Evans from getting to the ball. His movement in the video is not the movement of a player trying to get to a ball or move into a better position. His wide stance gives away that he does not plan on being moved.
He doesn't even attempt to jump for the ball that goes just over his head.

Watching the vid, it looks like a well rehearsed routine he executes it so perfectly.

We can say Evans fouls him before/after, but Evans is absolutely being fouled.

Once again, I do not expect these to be called.

View attachment 6813
Click to expand...
You are hardly neutral in this though. As I said, I’m struggling to find anyone without connections to Man Utd who thinks this was a foul. Indeed, I know several Man U supporting people who think it wasn’t a foul.
 
RustyRef said:
You are hardly neutral in this though. As I said, I’m struggling to find anyone without connections to Man Utd who thinks this was a foul. Indeed, I know several Man U supporting people who think it wasn’t a foul.
Click to expand...
Couldn’t agree more. The only people who think this was a foul are man United people.
No amount of evidence or professional opinion will change their mind.

I watched Ref Watch and the big decisions were perfectly analysed and spot on. Even the pundits all agreed. Yet a man United man says “refs protecting refs!” Even though the show week in and week out points out ref errors.

www.skysports.com

Ref Watch: All Arsenal vs Man Utd calls dissected by Dermot Gallagher

Plus: what was the really poor decision at the Etihad? Should Liverpools opener against Aston Villa have stood? Were Luton denied a penalty on FNF? Dermot Gallagher has his say in the latest Ref Watch...
www.skysports.com www.skysports.com
 
Ori said:
Couldn’t agree more. The only people who think this was a foul are man United people.
No amount of evidence or professional opinion will change their mind.

I watched Ref Watch and the big decisions were perfectly analysed and spot on. Even the pundits all agreed. Yet a man United man says “refs protecting refs!” Even though the show week in and week out points out ref errors.

www.skysports.com

Ref Watch: All Arsenal vs Man Utd calls dissected by Dermot Gallagher

Plus: what was the really poor decision at the Etihad? Should Liverpools opener against Aston Villa have stood? Were Luton denied a penalty on FNF? Dermot Gallagher has his say in the latest Ref Watch...
www.skysports.com www.skysports.com
Click to expand...
DG: "It could have been a foul the other way. They're both grappling with each other. In the end, Evans throws Gabriel out of the way."

So Dermot and I are in full agreement, as with all his other decisions, but somehow my view is wrong cos I'm a Man Utd fan and no amount of evidence could make me agree with the professionals? (Which I do already)

How's that work then?
 
deusex said:
DG: "It could have been a foul the other way. They're both grappling with each other. In the end, Evans throws Gabriel out of the way."

So Dermot and I are in full agreement, as with all his other decisions, but somehow my view is wrong cos I'm a Man Utd fan and no amount of evidence could make me agree with the professionals? (Which I do already)

How's that work then?
Click to expand...
Did Dermot say it should have been a penalty then? Full agreement, you are having a laugh 😂
 
deusex said:
DG: "It could have been a foul the other way. They're both grappling with each other. In the end, Evans throws Gabriel out of the way."

So Dermot and I are in full agreement, as with all his other decisions, but somehow my view is wrong cos I'm a Man Utd fan and no amount of evidence could make me agree with the professionals? (Which I do already)

How's that work then?
Click to expand...
Well, United fans are the only ones who think that the goal wasn’t offside. Arsenal second goal should have been ruled out. Oh and of course they deserved a penalty.

Reminds me of lover fans claiming that the red card was wrong.

Obviously not all United fans, but it’s just funny how tinted opinions are by the team they support. Human nature I guess. You see it in politics too.
 
Its utterly absurd that anyone is questioning the offside. Talk of lines in the wrong place etc...
It amounts to a whole new level of questioning decisions
Ten Hag started it. Moronic stuff
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ori
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top