NAP v JUV - Ronaldo Red

[Referee117]

What are we thinking on this one?

 

[MattTheRef]

No issues with it for me.

Probably could have stayed on his feet but it's a foul and it's a dogso.

 

[JH]

What are we thinking on this one?

Just DOGSO, had my doubts but if you say Ronaldo isn't fouled there I think he gets that ball before it goes too wide.

 

[deusex]

DOGSO, SFP
Take your pick
Ronaldo felt the contact and gone down but still a foul

 

[alexgr]

Is there any contact there whatsoever? Struggling to see

 

[Ciley Myrus]

Nobody should need the safety net of VAR for that one, its a routine keeper takes down striker decision, minimal, or some, or lots of, contact, totally irrelevant.

My point of interest was procedure wise on this one ( I watched it live), ref, (correctly as it turns out) shows gk red, then VAR reviews it, before ref says to keeper, yes, your off, maybe (to save having to rescind the red) there is a way of stopping play, then waiting for the confirmation before issuing the red??

 

[one]

Nobody should need the safety net of VAR for that one, its a routine keeper takes down striker decision, minimal, or some, or lots of, contact, totally irrelevant.

My point of interest was procedure wise on this one ( I watched it live), ref, (correctly as it turns out) shows gk red, then VAR reviews it, before ref says to keeper, yes, your off, maybe (to save having to rescind the red) there is a way of stopping play, then waiting for the confirmation before issuing the red??

No. That would make it look like the red is on the advice of VAR. Public should know what the original ref decision was and if he changed it after review.

 

[Ciley Myrus]

No. That would make it look like the red is on the advice of VAR. Public should know what the original ref decision was and if he changed it after review.

Then as we had a few weeks ago, should we have a standardised "resinding of red card" signal??
I actually liked how the ref dealt with it, but, that's not my concern.

 

[one]

For me unofficial singnal is fine but I don't mind if there was an official one.
There are other things a referee is required to do but there is no official signal for. Giving permission for substitution, entering or leaving the the FOP comes to mind now.