Whats with the rhetorical questions?And this is relevant in what way??
Last edited:
What are you giving?
- Thread starter JH
- Start date
Russell Jones
RefChat Addict
Definitely not rhetorical. And in my opinion, not nonsense either!
Just think that introducing the notion of the GK's intent is completely spurious. All that matters is whether his challenge is Careless, Reckless etc. And I see it as Reckless (at least). You're obviously free to disagree with this point of view but doing so because he 'didn't mean it' is deeply unhelpful!!
Nonsense in the way it was asked without a counter argument! A GK is a defender, he’s done his job with the tools at his disposal. Fair contact for me. Jeez, if every contact was a foul we wouldn’t get far as a spectacle. He hasn’t crossed a fouling line for me....throw in.... next