A&H

“off you pop”

The Referee Store
It's all about Dean
Shame it was effectively a wrongful dismissal, one which can't be appealed against despite a mistaken identity element
 
Big Cat said:
It's all about Dean
Shame it was effectively a wrongful dismissal, one which can't be appealed against despite a mistaken identity element
Click to expand...
Don't think it was mistaken identity. Think Dean was looking at the feet rather than up high and saw (or thought he saw) a foul by Dunk that stopped a promising attack. You can absolutely debate that decision but not s situation where he simply picked the wrong player ....
 
Russell Jones said:
Don't think it was mistaken identity. Think Dean was looking at the feet rather than up high and saw (or thought he saw) a foul by Dunk that stopped a promising attack. You can absolutely debate that decision but not s situation where he simply picked the wrong player ....
Click to expand...
Yup, that's why I added the 'element' clause
The dismissal was a mistake however it was arrived at. Takes the sheen off of, 'off you pop'
Dean was one of the very best. I've just grown long in the tooth with him; hence my insolent view of this phrase when used as an accompaniment to a mistake
 
Big Cat said:
Yup, that's why I added the 'element' clause
The dismissal was a mistake however it was arrived at. Takes the sheen off of, 'off you pop'
Dean was one of the very best. I've just grown long in the tooth with him; hence my insolent view of this phrase when used as an accompaniment to a mistake
Click to expand...
dean.jpg
Big Dog!! :angel: 1 @Big Cat 0 :smoke:
 
I can see why he gave Dunk the first yellow. The attacker was fouled by another defender but Dunk took a swipe too. Seemed a bit harsh but certainly not wrong. I still think Mike Dean's up there with the best of them.
 
OK, had my grumpy head on last night :meh:
The SPA for Dunk was wrong. That was a 'given'
 
QPR v Wigan April 2013

Phil Dowd: Zamora - over here
Bobby Zamora: WTF, I didn't to.......(hand to ear listening to comms)

Bobby - you're off son! (where's the biscuits?)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top