Man City v Arsenal

[Paul_10]

I can’t see that it was excessive force or brutality. Although I usually always like to compare apples with apples and oranges with oranges, as to hair pulls (not this incident of course), which are not usually excessive force, but are seen by the PL/FA etc as an act of brutality (at the moment anyway) & I can live with that.

If that type of contact was with the hand in a forward movement, it be an automatic red card like it was with Gueye's slap which let face it was not excessive force(I doubt Keane had a red slap mark on his face) but it's still a red card.

If Taylor only gives a yellow card in a World Cup game for a similar incident, that would probably be his World Cup finished.

 

[DavidObs]

If that type of contact was with the hand in a forward movement, it be an automatic red card like it was with Gueye's slap which let face it was not excessive force(I doubt Keane had a red slap mark on his face) but it's still a red card.

If Taylor only gives a yellow card in a World Cup game for a similar incident, that would probably be his World Cup finished.

Yes, you are probably right if it happens in the World Cup, or any other FIFA/UEFA competition, but they have different interpretations on many things, including handball. Same Laws/different interpretation.

 

[betterlatethannever]

I am sure this type of action has been a red card for at least the last 20 years?

Any movement from the head forwards to the other player has been a red card and I am sure until yesterday this was universally seen to be a red? Even with less forward force people have been sent off with pundits suggesting that players know any movement and you're being sent off.

Just not yesterday obviously! I do not necessarily mind it - but as you say, I would 99% of the time be sending someone off for this, so now the referee in the most high profile game of the season and probably most watched hasn't, it makes it harder for me!

 

[DavidObs]

I am sure this type of action has been a red card for at least the last 20 years?

Any movement from the head forwards to the other player has been a red card and I am sure until yesterday this was universally seen to be a red? Even with less forward force people have been sent off with pundits suggesting that players know any movement and you're being sent off.

Just not yesterday obviously! I do not necessarily mind it - but as you say, I would 99% of the time be sending someone off for this, so now the referee in the most high profile game of the season and probably most watched hasn't, it makes it harder for me!

I can’t say that I recall too many similar incidents in the PL over the past 20 years when both players put their heads together with only 1 making an additional forward movement. However, I can truly understand it being harder for you to send off in same circumstances - though perhaps same could be said for players/club reps using offensive, insulting or abusive language.

 

[BCMilan]

Red for me. As you say, if you don't give red's for those then all you're doing is encouraging players to act injured. And yes, they've just made it that much harder for those of us at grassroots

 

[bester]

Certainly more violent than any hair pull we've seen punished and striking has a far lower threshold