Seems to be a hot debate from yesterday.
Match of the day panel were even split, some saying Gilmour's wasn't a red![Astonished face :astonished: š²](https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/joypixels/assets/8.0/png/unicode/64/1f632.png)
For me, both are stonewall red cards as they tick this criteria exceeds the necessary use of force and endangers the safety of an opponent and must be sent off
Add to the debate Caicedo who has just ended Gravenberch's league cup final with an equally horrific tackle.
![1708876818122.png 1708876818122.png](https://refchat.co.uk/data/attachments/7/7154-8776aeb68f42dc1c262cb3e87eaf3cc0.jpg)
![1708877356903.png 1708877356903.png](https://refchat.co.uk/data/attachments/7/7155-2d8d2707955cf4184ce4b824ee3d9080.jpg)
www.skysports.com
Match of the day panel were even split, some saying Gilmour's wasn't a red
![Astonished face :astonished: š²](https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/joypixels/assets/8.0/png/unicode/64/1f632.png)
For me, both are stonewall red cards as they tick this criteria exceeds the necessary use of force and endangers the safety of an opponent and must be sent off
Add to the debate Caicedo who has just ended Gravenberch's league cup final with an equally horrific tackle.
![1708876818122.png 1708876818122.png](https://refchat.co.uk/data/attachments/7/7154-8776aeb68f42dc1c262cb3e87eaf3cc0.jpg)
![1708877356903.png 1708877356903.png](https://refchat.co.uk/data/attachments/7/7155-2d8d2707955cf4184ce4b824ee3d9080.jpg)
![www.skysports.com](/proxy.php?image=https%3A%2F%2Fe0.365dm.com%2F24%2F02%2F1600x900%2Fskysports-billy-gilmour-harry_6468342.jpg%3F20240224193343&hash=705307d5f316a377a1ba6668df46902f&return_error=1)
Billy Gilmour's red versus Harry Maguire's yellow - Was there a difference?
How much of a difference was there between the red card challenge of Billy Gilmour and that of Harry Maguire which only received a booking?