Liverpool v Man U

lincs22

Supply League Observer

Staff member

Observer/Tutor

• Dec 17, 2023

• #1

One sided start to the match, but good awareness by the AR for the Nunez barge and YC given.

Could have got another for the sarcastic applauding of the decision?

 

RefGod

Active Member

• Dec 17, 2023

• #2

lincs22 said:

One sided start to the match, but good awareness by the AR for the Nunez barge and YC given.

Could have got another for the sarcastic applauding of the decision?

Click to expand...

Should've been second caution for sarcasting clapping.

 

N

N416405

Waterman

• Dec 17, 2023

• #3

Looked like the yellow was for kicking the ball away?

 

T

Therealcjhill

Well-Known Member

• Dec 17, 2023

• #4

Salah offside in his own half, came back from offside and Oliver made UTd take FK back in their own half, from the point Salah came from.

 

R

Runner-Ref

Guest

• Dec 17, 2023

• #5

N416405 said:

Looked like the yellow was for kicking the ball away?

Click to expand...

Yeah, I think Oliver points to say it was for kicking the ball away

 

R

Runner-Ref

Guest

• Dec 17, 2023

• #6

Therealcjhill said:

Salah offside in his own half, came back from offside and Oliver made UTd take FK back in their own half, from the point Salah came from.

Click to expand...

I thought I was the only one who saw that! Or at least seeing things

 

L

ladbroke8745

RefChat Addict

• Dec 17, 2023

• #7

Thought Endos caution was harsh. Looked like the United player ducked down to win the header with Endo actually looking like he pulled out.

 

GraemeS

RefChat Addict

Level 5 Referee

• Dec 17, 2023

• #8

N416405 said:

Looked like the yellow was for kicking the ball away?

Click to expand...

Agree, which seems a little harsh given it was nearly a perfect lob over an advanced keeper! Will have to watch again to see the timing of the whistle and if it's obvious Nunez has heard it before shooting.

MO unsurprisingly having a good game so far, aside from being slightly conned for the Endo yellow. Taking bets on how many United DTR yellows will come if this stays 0-0 until late on?

 

T

Therealcjhill

Well-Known Member

• Dec 17, 2023

• #9

Why won’t refs yellow card clear dives. Oliver has waved away Szob dive straight away. Get the card out.

 

RefGod

Active Member

• Dec 17, 2023

• #10

Therealcjhill said:

Why won’t refs yellow card clear dives. Oliver has waved away Szob dive straight away. Get the card out.

Click to expand...

Odd considering his great shout with Palmer recently.

 

Mooseybaby

Retired big bad baldy in all black!

• Dec 17, 2023

• #11

Seen an u15 get a 2nd yellow/red card for sarcastically applauding the referee immediately after getting the first yellow for persistent infringement.

Not the cleverest of challenges by Luke Shaw.

 

RefGod

Active Member

• Dec 17, 2023

• #12

Oliver isn't in the best of form and this nonsense at the end of the fixture epitomises it. Lazy refereeing.

 

N

N416405

Waterman

• Dec 17, 2023

• #13

Therealcjhill said:

Why won’t refs yellow card clear dives. Oliver has waved away Szob dive straight away. Get the card out.

Click to expand...

Same for dissent gesturing - it's visible to everyone, no debate, it's plain and simple ... apply the laws!

Now he does two dissents in 2-seconds.

From one extreme to another.

 

Mooseybaby

Retired big bad baldy in all black!

• Dec 17, 2023

• #14

Wow! Dallot red after quick fire yellows for 2 acts of dissent. Pick the bones out of that one.

 

deusex

RefChat Addict

• Dec 17, 2023

• #15

If I speak, I will be banned from this forum for life.

 

E

es1

RefChat Addict

• Dec 17, 2023

• #16

Mooseybaby said:

Wow! Dallot red after quick fire yellows for 2 acts of dissent. Pick the bones out of that one.

Click to expand...

Would have helped if he'd got the throw right

I feel 2 yellows is harsh

 

J

Josh the referee

Well-Known Member

Level 7 Referee

• Dec 17, 2023

• #17

es1 said:

Would have helped if he'd got the throw right

I feel 2 yellows is harsh

Click to expand...

No one knows what he said.

More than happy with 2 yellows here, especially considering the way he reacted over a throw in

 

GraemeS

RefChat Addict

Level 5 Referee

• Dec 17, 2023

• #18

es1 said:

Would have helped if he'd got the throw right

I feel 2 yellows is harsh

Click to expand...

It's tricky when you get the card out for a very specific gesture and the player then repeats that exact same gesture in response. The definition of consistency!

 

Mooseybaby

Retired big bad baldy in all black!

• Dec 17, 2023

• #19

Wonder what he said, but after Nunez escaped a 2nd yellow for his response, United won't be happy.

 

S

SammyT5

Well-Known Member

Level 7 Referee

• Dec 17, 2023

• #20

I feel for MO to give a second yellow here he’s said something pretty bad.