This. Needs to become the norm, none of this 'free shot because you got a card'. Stamp this crap out.Absolutely fantastic. I hope more follow suit!
What would the procedure be for something like this where you use sin bins? Could you issue a double sin bin yellow and them allow the player to be replaced after 20 minutes? Or would you only give one sin bin in the hope it calms the player down?
Obviously in this match a sin bin would have achieved the same result as a red (apart from the subsequent ban)
I'm not sure that's correct? Once the first card is shown, the player is effectively "in the sin bin" from that moment forwards, even if he stands in the exact same spot. And once in the sin bin:In this situation it would be a yellow for 1st dissent and yellow for 2nd dissent. 20 minutes in the sin bin. After that time, the player cannot return but can be substituted if not all subs have been used. Or you could just upgrade to OFFINABUS depending on words or gestures used.....
A temporarily dismissed player who commits a cautionable (YC) or sending-off (RC) offence during their temporary dismissal period will take no further part in the match and may not be replaced or substituted
I'm not sure that's correct? Once the first card is shown, the player is effectively "in the sin bin" from that moment forwards, even if he stands in the exact same spot. And once in the sin bin:
A temporarily dismissed player who commits a cautionable (YC) or sending-off (RC) offence during their temporary dismissal period will take no further part in the match and may not be replaced or substituted
BT Sport channel on youtube, CSKA Moscow vs Real MadridSomething is not right.
Maybe. You still show a yellow card for a sin bin though, so I'd argue that sin binning is a subset of YC offences, rather than something distinct?i know very little about sin bins so i'm playing with words a little here...but, surely in this instance the player has not committed either a red or yellow card offence, he has committed a sinbinnable (is that a word now?!) offence, so is that different?!
But a sin bin + a caution doesn't make a RC so you could argue that it's not a subset of YC offences. Needless to say it's not very clearMaybe. You still show a yellow card for a sin bin though, so I'd argue that sin binning is a subset of YC offences, rather than something distinct?
Good evening Trueman1991But a sin bin + a caution doesn't make a RC so you could argue that it's not a subset of YC offences. Needless to say it's not very clear
One agrees..What makes me laugh most about this is the standing ovation he gets from the fans. If my keeper got sent off for something so stupid the last thing i would be doing is clapping him off the pitch........embarrassing!!!
I have to disagree strongly with this: lots of the LOTG is subjective and has to be so by necessity, because it's difficult to write a book that describes in detail every possible thing that could happen on a football pitch. This is a situation where you've shown two consecutive cards and there SHOULD be a clear correct answer, because it's a very distinct situation that will happen.Good evening Trueman1991
Yes well said but like many
decisions in the beautiful game.. It is open to the
Interpretations of the Law based on what the referee/referees seen..