Russell Jones
RefChat Addict
At the risk of being pedantic, yes I do try to sin bin / YC for every piece of dissent. In the same way a tackle that you decide is Reckless is a mandatory yellow card, so is disagreement that reaches the level of dissent. However, there is plenty of disagreement with decisions that doesn't reach the / your threshold ... and this can and should be managed exactly as you describe. I just find life is simpler if you make a clear distinction between the two and only use the word dissent to describe words and actions that constitute a sanctionable offence.dissent (do you sin bin for every bit of dissent that comes your way or do you manage using the Step process etc?). After all, the step process is simply managing a situation. The law for dissent by word or action required a sin bin at steps 5 and below.....