The Ref Stop

Pen shoot out

Donate to RefChat

Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated

The Ref Stop
ladbroke8745 said:
Saw this video on Facebook...
Lots of comments suggesting goal.
My understanding, in a penalty shoot out, it's not a goal.

www.facebook.com

5.4K views · 10K reactions | That’s crazy 🤣📱 @jdlmoney | JDL money

That’s crazy 🤣📱 @jdlmoney
www.facebook.com www.facebook.com
Click to expand...
??
A penalty is complete when the ball goes out of play, stops moving or the referee stops play for an offence.
I want to say that law changed specifically to be clear that the goal stands in these scenarios. Would have to go digging to confirm but certainly nothing to suggest it's not a goal in a shootout.
Law 10 for reference
 
That’s definitely a goal. I can’t remember which game but I definitely remember seeing this sort of thing happen before, where a goal was (correctly) awarded. As James said, Law 10 covers this.
 
JamesL said:
??
A penalty is complete when the ball goes out of play, stops moving or the referee stops play for an offence.
I want to say that law changed specifically to be clear that the goal stands in these scenarios. Would have to go digging to confirm but certainly nothing to suggest it's not a goal in a shootout.
Law 10 for reference
Click to expand...
If I'm being technical here. The keeper does technically stop the ball. He does grab it and let's it go immediately and, unfortunately, into the goal.
That's why I'm thinking it shouldn't be a goal.
 
ladbroke8745 said:
If I'm being technical here. The keeper does technically stop the ball. He does grab it and let's it go immediately and, unfortunately, into the goal.
That's why I'm thinking it shouldn't be a goal.
Click to expand...
The referee didn't signal an offence, the ball didn't stop moving and it didn't go out of play. So what do you think supports it not being a goal?
 
I know we’re talking about a different sport, and I’m sort of stepping outside of the law here also, but as another angle, would you consider that to be a catch if it happened in a cricket match? Pretty sure that would be given not out as he didn’t ever have control of the ball before releasing it.
It definitely counts as scored.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top